mirror of
https://github.com/danny-avila/LibreChat.git
synced 2026-11-19 14:33:38 +00:00
3 commits
| Author | SHA1 | Message | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
|
f02ce63d57
|
✂️ fix: Strip Redundant Server-Name Prefixes from MCP Tool Keys (#14732)
* ✂️ fix: Strip Redundant Server-Name Prefixes from MCP Tool Keys MCP servers that prefix every tool with their own name produce model-facing keys that embed the server twice once the _mcp_<server> suffix is appended, pushing long tool names past provider 64-character function-name limits. Tool keys now drop a leading <normalizedServerName>_ prefix (case-insensitive, skipped when a sibling tool already owns the stripped name). The original upstream name is recorded as serverToolName on the cached definition and is always what tool calls send to the server, and runtime lookups also try the stripped spelling of persisted pre-strip keys so existing agents keep resolving. * 🩹 fix: Keep Stripped MCP Tool Keys Provider-Safe and Collision-Free Assistant writers submit catalog entries verbatim, so the internal serverToolName mapping is now removed from provider-facing definitions before they reach create/update payloads. Prefix stripping is collision-guarded over the resulting name set rather than raw siblings only, which also covers case-variant prefixed pairs under the case-insensitive match. Assistant payload healing now rewrites a pre-strip persisted key to the stripped catalog key when that key actually exists in the loaded definitions, and legacy agent references keep their persisted spelling as the runtime instance name so per-tool options stay applied while the upstream call still uses the matched entry's raw name. * 🧷 fix: Harden Stripped MCP Tool Keys Against Heal, Collision, and Cache Edges The pre-strip heal now resolves the key boundary against both raw and normalized server spellings, mapping back to the raw name for the shadow and membership guards, so keys persisted after server-name normalization heal too. Collision detection iterates to a fixpoint so a fallback to a raw name cannot silently collide with another sibling's stripped result, and a stripped remainder equal to a synthetic marker (wildcard or server pin) is never produced. MCP catalog cache slices are versioned so replicas that predate serverToolName never read stripped entries during a rolling deploy; stale slices expire on their own. * 🔎 fix: Resolve Pre-Strip Keys in Event-Driven Definitions and Reinspect Persisted Catalogs The event-driven definitions loader now tries the stripped spelling of a persisted key when the exact lookup misses, keeping the persisted name so it matches the runtime instance, which stops legacy agents from failing initialization with expected tools unavailable. The registry storage schema version is bumped so followers rebuild persisted toolFunctions instead of republishing pre-strip definitions into the versioned catalog namespace. The assistants heal also fails closed when a normalized-suffix reference lands on a contested server-name slot, since rewriting persisted data must not bind an ambiguous reference to the tie-break winner. * 🛰️ fix: Reserve the Synthetic OAuth Name and Heal User-Owned Server Keys A stripped remainder equal to oauth would make the client stream handlers treat a real tool call as a synthetic authentication prompt, so it joins the reserved remainders alongside the wildcard and pin markers. The assistants heal now audits the FULL accessible server set on every run instead of operator config names only, since assistants reference user-owned servers whose catalogs the definitions loader already resolves; an unavailable audit still skips healing entirely. * 🧬 fix: Verify Upstream Identity for Legacy Keys and Reserve Sibling Raw Names Stripped results now reserve every sibling's raw name even when that sibling itself strips, so a stripped key can never shadow another tool's pre-rollout persisted references within the same snapshot. Every legacy fallback (runtime lookup, event-driven definitions, assistants heal) accepts a stripped-spelling match only when the entry's recorded serverToolName proves the same upstream tool, so a stale key for a removed tool degrades to unavailable instead of calling a different sibling. To keep that identity visible to the heal, assistant tool definitions retain serverToolName and the controllers sanitize entries through toProviderToolDefinition at the provider submission boundary instead. The agent editor migrates pre-strip persisted ids the same identity-verified way, with the upstream name exposed on the MCP tools payload. * 🧭 fix: Heal Wildcard Tool Options and Reserve the OAuth Namespace Wildcard-expanded catalogs rename stripped tools without any agent.tools entry to preserve the spelling, so buildToolClassification now aliases persisted pre-strip tool_options keys onto the current instance names in place, identity-gated on the definition's recorded upstream name and never overriding an explicit entry. Both loading modes flow through it: instances carry mcpServerToolName from createToolInstance and event-driven definitions thread serverToolName from the catalog. stripServerNamePrefix also reserves the entire oauth namespace rather than the exact name, since the client stream handlers classify every oauth-prefixed key as a synthetic authentication call. * 🛡️ fix: Derive the Full Reserved Namespace and Heal Approval Policies The reservation guard now covers every namespace consumers classify by prefix: the wildcard and server-pin markers alongside oauth, plus the server-scoped mcp_ pluginKey namespace that pre-strip keys could never enter. Stripping also never produces a key whose isActionTool classification differs from the raw key's, since a server whose normalized name contains _action_ would otherwise see a real MCP tool routed down the OpenAPI action path past MCP authorization. Admin toolApproval globs written against upstream tool naming keep applying: pattern lists are healed at run wiring with the current names of tools whose pre-strip spelling matches, list-level so deny, ask, and allow precedence is unchanged and a non-matching deny can no longer fail open. The MCP tools wire type also declares serverToolName end to end. * 🪪 fix: Alias Both Key Spellings for Approval Policies and Hook Matchers Identity aliases are now collected once at tool classification, in both directions: a stripped instance aliases its pre-strip spelling and a legacy-named instance aliases its current catalog spelling, with the current name recorded on legacy matches by the runtime lookup and the event-driven definitions loader alike. The aliases ride the agent config through both loading modes, so approval pattern healing applies to deny rules written against either spelling, closing the bypass where a rule targeting the current name missed an unedited agent's legacy instance. Programmatic approval hook matchers get the same treatment: each hook is additionally registered under an anchored exact-name pattern for tools whose other spelling its regex matches, keeping the admin's matcher semantics intact while argument, user, and tenant specific deny or ask decisions keep executing for renamed tools. * 🔁 fix: Alias Tool Options in Both Spelling Directions Options aliasing now consumes the same bidirectional alias pairs as policy healing and hook matchers, so options the editor migrated to the current catalog spelling still reach a legacy-named instance retained by an unedited agent.tools entry. The previous serverToolName-only derivation skipped exactly that case since the legacy key equals the instance name there. * 🤝 fix: Reserve the Agent Handoff Namespace Before Stripping The client renders any lc_transfer_to_ prefixed call as an agent handoff and the background and intent passes exclude such names, so a stripped remainder inside that namespace would misclassify a real upstream tool. It joins the mcp_ pluginKey namespace as a bare-prefix reservation, which pre-strip keys could never enter. * ⚡ fix: Reuse the Loader's Server Snapshot and Index the Editor Catalog getAssistantToolDefinitions now returns the accessible-server snapshot from the same merged registry read that resolved the catalogs, and the heal consumes it instead of repeating the app-config and registry round trips on the assistant write path; without a snapshot the heal still fetches and fails closed as before. The agent editor's id migration uses a memoized tool_id map, so the per-key form heal does constant-time lookups instead of scanning the catalog per option. --------- Co-authored-by: Danny Avila <danny@librechat.ai> |
||
|
|
6f45a9e32e
|
🔗 fix: Normalize MCP Tool Keys at Every Producer, Resolve Raw Names via Aliases (#14553)
* 🔗 fix: Normalize MCP Tool Keys at Every Producer, Resolve Raw Names via Aliases Tool keys had two spellings that could diverge for any server whose name contains characters outside [a-zA-Z0-9_.-]: the tool cache (and registry inspector) built keys with the RAW server name, while runtime instances are named with normalizeServerName(serverName). Three code comments already asserted "tool keys embed the normalized server name" - no producer honored it. For a special-character server that meant: - definitions-only mode shipped raw def names the model echoed back, but the executor's tool map held the normalized instance name, so every call failed with "Tool not found"; - per-tool tool_options (defer_loading / allowed_callers / run_in_background / describe_intent) were persisted under raw keys that never matched the definition names the option passes resolve against, so builder settings were silently inert; - tool-key parsing against normalized candidate lists silently fell back to last-delimiter splitting, which mis-parses delimiter-bearing tool names. The reconciliation is one contract enforced in three moves: 1. PRODUCERS NORMALIZE. The tool cache (packages/api/src/mcp/tools.ts) and the registry inspector build keys with the normalized server name, matching the instance names MCP.js has always assigned. The builder's tool ids, agent.tools entries, tool_options keys, and definition names all flow from these keys, so every model-facing name now agrees. The cache STORE stays keyed by the raw config name. 2. CONFIG LOOKUPS RESOLVE ALIASES. New shared helpers in data-provider (buildServerNameAliases, normalizeMCPToolKey) map a parsed normalized name back to the raw config name that the registry, config maps, tool cache, and plugin-auth rows are keyed by. Applied in the definitions loader closure, handleTools grouping, createMCPTool's parsing fallback, getUserMCPAuthMap, and the MCP tools endpoint - matching both spellings so legacy raw keys keep resolving. 3. LEGACY DATA HEALS AT ONE BOUNDARY. initializeAgent rewrites raw-keyed agent.tools entries and tool_options keys to the normalized form (normalizeAgentToolKeys) before anything consumes them, so agents persisted under the old convention load their tools AND have all four per-tool options honored. Placeholder and server-pin tokens stay raw - they are config-identity references, not model-facing names. Servers whose names are already in the safe character set (the common case) produce byte-identical keys before and after; the fast path allocates nothing. Stale Redis-cached raw keys self-heal via the existing reconnect-on-missing path within one cache cycle. * 🧯 fix: Deterministic Alias Collisions + Raw Names in Definition Metadata Two review findings on the normalization contract: - Two configured server names that normalize to the same segment (e.g. 'Sales Force' and 'Sales:Force' -> 'Sales_Force') produce inherently ambiguous tool keys; the alias map silently resolved last-wins, so a tool selected from one server could execute against the other's config. buildServerNameAliases now resolves collisions to the FIRST configured name deterministically, and resolveMCPServerContext warns once per colliding pair per process so the operator can rename one server. A collision-resistant identifier would change every existing tool key, so detection + stable routing is the right treatment here; startup-time config validation can follow separately. - The definitions loader resolved parsed (normalized) server names to raw only inside the ToolService closure, while the definition metadata (serverName -> mcpRawServerName) kept the normalized value. Server instructions are keyed by raw config names, so a special-character server's instructions were silently omitted in definitions-only mode. loadToolDefinitions now takes rawServerNames, resolves the boundary against both spellings, and stores the RAW name in definition metadata - consistent with the instance path. * 🧯 fix: Heal Stale Caches, Skill Allowed-Tools, and Builder Selectors Three review findings on the normalization rollout, all in the transition class: - Stale cache entries (P1): the definitions-only loader treats the per-server tool map as authoritative and never reconnects on a per-key miss, so a pre-change raw-keyed Redis entry would make a special-character server's tools vanish for up to the cache TTL. getMCPServerTools now heals legacy raw-keyed entries to the normalized format at read time (keys and function names), covering every consumer with no coordinated invalidation; safe names return the map untouched. - Skill allowed-tools: a skill declaring a raw MCP key in allowed-tools bypassed the initialize-boundary heal (the union runs after it) and would neither dedupe against healed agent tools nor match the normalized tool map. The primes' allowedTools now pass through the same normalizeAgentToolKeys heal before unioning. - Builder selectors: matchesMcpServer and useVisibleTools parsed tool ids against raw server names only, so an attached special-character server rendered as an unselected orphan card. Both now accept the normalized spelling and resolve it back to the raw map key, keeping legacy raw ids working. * 🧯 fix: Fail Closed on Normalized Server-Name Collisions Escalation of the collision finding: a deterministic first-wins alias plus a warning still let the tools listing publish BOTH colliding servers, so a tool selected under the shadowed second server would silently execute against the first server's configuration (their model-facing keys are identical, so routing cannot ever distinguish them). - findShadowedServerNames identifies later-configured names whose normalized form an earlier different name claimed. - getMCPTools excludes shadowed servers from the published listing entirely (with a warn naming the collision), so their tools are never selectable - nothing ambiguous can be picked. - Server creation reserves both spellings: a generated slug may not collide with a raw config name OR the normalized form its tool keys would carry. Collision-resistant model-facing IDs remain out of scope: changing normalizeServerName's output would rewrite every existing tool key (agent documents, caches, instance names) for ALL servers to handle a misconfiguration that is now blocked from exposure instead. * ✅ fix: Dedupe Reserved Server-Name Spellings at Creation The reservation list appended normalized forms unconditionally, which duplicated every safe name (raw === normalized) and broke the route-level contract test pinning the exact list. Dedupe via a Set so safe names contribute one entry, while special-character names still reserve both spellings; adds the special-character reservation case. * 🧯 fix: Never Heal a Shadowed Server's Keys; Align Authorization Tie-Break Persisted references were the remaining collision vector: an agent or skill saved with the shadowed later server's raw key was HEALED into the shared normalized key, authorized through a last-wins map, and routed first-wins - authorized as one server, executed as another. - normalizeAgentToolKeys now refuses to rewrite keys of shadowed servers (findShadowedServerNames): rewriting would produce exactly the first server's key. Left raw, the key cannot match the normalized-keyed tool map and the tool fails visibly - broken beats misrouted. Covers agent.tools, tool_options, and skill allowed-tools through the shared heal. - filterAuthorizedTools (agents/v1.js) builds its normalized-to-raw map via the shared buildServerNameAliases instead of a last-wins Map constructor, so authorization resolves a colliding key to the SAME first server execution routes to. * 🧯 fix: Direct Identity Wins Over Aliases; Heal Client Forms and Degraded Contexts Four review findings on the normalization edges: - Alias hijack (P1): a user-DB server named exactly like an operator server's normalized form ('foo' vs YAML 'foo!') had its tools rerouted to the operator server by unconditional alias resolution. Resolution is now DIRECT-FIRST everywhere: the parsed name is tried as-is, and only when nothing resolves is it treated as a normalized spelling (definitions loader, handleTools grouping, createMCPTool fallback). buildServerNameAliases seats identity entries before derived ones so a literal name owns its slot regardless of config order, findShadowedServerNames and the collision warning derive from the same construction, and getUserMCPAuthMap fetches auth under both spellings so either owner finds its rows. - Builder double-match: a normalized name containing the delimiter ('foo mcp bar' -> 'foo_mcp_bar') also suffix-matched a server named 'bar', selecting both cards and making removal strip the wrong tool. matchesMcpServer now resolves the token ONCE against the full configured list (longest boundary, both spellings) when the caller supplies it; selection and removal share the resolution. - Builder legacy ids: an agent saved with raw-keyed ids showed its tools unchecked while the runtime heal kept them active, and selection updates never replaced the legacy entries. McpSection maps legacy raw ids to their current normalized ids when deriving and rewriting this server's selection. - Degraded context: a transient ensureConfigServers failure returned an entirely empty context, leaving normalized keys unresolvable for the request. resolveMCPServerContext now keeps the name lists (they derive from the config snapshot alone) and degrades only the lazy-init configs. * 🧯 fix: Collision Detection Sees Accessible Servers; Shadowed Refs Fail Closed End to End Round follow-ups on the collision design, all in the DB-server-visibility class: - The legacy-key heal detected collisions against operator-config names only, so healing could still produce a key that direct-first resolution routes to an invisible user-DB server. initializeAgent gains an optional getAccessibleMcpServerNames dep (wired through ToolService for controllers that mock it, directly elsewhere), consulted ONLY when a configured name needs normalization - zero cost for safe-name deployments. The heal then sees the full accessible set and skips shadowed servers' keys. - Wildcard and legacy raw tokens bypassed catalog filtering, letting a shadowed server's instances join a run under the same normalized names as the winner's. filterAuthorizedTools rejects tools of shadowed servers at authorization (its merged map sees DB + config), and handleTools skips them at execution. - The builder migrated only tool selection, not tool_options: legacy raw option keys showed disabled while the runtime honored them, and toggles could not clear them. McpSection now migrates option keys to the current normalized ids (existing normalized entries win). - A transient ensureConfigServers failure degraded to an EMPTY server context, leaving normalized keys unresolvable for the request. resolveMCPServerContext keeps the name lists (derived from the config snapshot alone) and degrades only the lazy-init configs. * 🧯 fix: Complete the Collision Audit at Every Gate; Safer Heal Semantics Round follow-ups hardening the collision audit: - Execution guards now consult the FULL accessible set: the caller's heal threads its already-fetched names through loadTools, and handleTools fetches them itself when a configured name needs normalization (never for safe-name deployments) - so a cross-tier collision (user-DB 'foo' vs operator 'foo!') fails closed at eager execution instead of joining the run under one normalized name. - Healing is SKIPPED when the collision audit cannot complete (transient lookup failure, or no dep): un-healed raw keys still resolve through the direct-first candidates, so skipping is safe while rewriting against an incomplete audit is not. - The audit lookup is gated on the agent actually carrying delimiter-bearing keys (tools, tool_options, or skill allowed-tools), so non-MCP agents never pay a registry round-trip even on specially named deployments. - normalizeAgentToolKeys gives the CURRENT (normalized) entry precedence when both spellings carry options, matching the builder's migration semantics instead of letting insertion order decide. - The builder's toCurrentToolId resolves entries boundary-exactly against every configured server (longest match, both spellings), so a raw suffix shared with a LONGER server name can no longer reassign that server's selection or options while another dialog is open. * 🧯 fix: Shared Collision Audit for Definitions Loading; Fail Closed on Audit Failure Round follow-ups closing the remaining audit gaps: - The definitions-only loader now consumes the same collision audit as eager loading: shadowed servers' entries (wildcards included) are dropped before definitions are emitted, so the default execution path can never resolve a shadowed server's normalized function name to another server. The audit names thread from initializeAgent's heal; the loader self-fetches only when a configured name needs normalization. - resolveCollisionAuditNames centralizes the audit-resolution policy (threaded set > self-fetch when needed > incomplete on failure), and BOTH loaders now fail closed under an incomplete audit: any normalization-sensitive reference (its own name needs normalizing, or it equals the normalized form of a configured special-character name) is skipped with a warning instead of being audited against operator names alone. isNormalizationSensitiveName lives in packages/api as a pure helper so test mocks use the real predicate. - normalizeAgentToolKeys collapses duplicate ids after healing (order-preserving): a document carrying both spellings converges on one key, never two instances with the same function name. * 🧯 fix: Thread the Audit Everywhere; Identity-Aware Alias Fallback Round follow-ups on audit plumbing: - The OpenAI-compatible and Responses tool loaders now forward the already-resolved accessibleMcpServerNames instead of discarding it, so the definitions loader neither repeats the registry lookup nor fails closed on a transient second lookup after the first succeeded. - The skill-only path threads its audit: when the baseline agent has no MCP keys but a primed skill's allowed-tools fetched the complete set, that set (not the operator-only list) reaches the loader, so the collision remains visible and the shadowed reference stays rejected end to end. - OAuth discovery iterates the collision-FILTERED tool list, so a request can no longer emit an OAuth prompt, wait out the connection timeout, and reconnect a server whose definitions were deliberately rejected. - The definitions loader's alias fallback is identity-aware: when the parsed name IS a known accessible server, a null tool fetch means temporarily unavailable (OAuth pending, missing user variables, disconnected) and no longer reroutes to the raw alias - previously the aliased operator server's definitions could be emitted under the unavailable DB server's names. * 🧯 fix: Legacy-Key Definition Lookup; Retain Audit for Deferred Execution - createMCPTool resolves tool definitions by BOTH spellings: the key as persisted plus the canonical normalized key built from the resolved server name. Assistants and direct tool calls persisted before the rollout bypass the agent-boundary heal and arrive with raw keys, while availableTools is now indexed canonically - previously every such call missed the index, burned a reconnect, and returned the unavailable stub permanently via the negative cache. - The initialized agent retains accessibleMcpServerNames (the COMPLETE collision audit this initialization resolved), buildAgentToolContext copies it into every per-agent tool context, and loadToolsForExecution threads it into the eager loader as bare options. Deferred/event-driven execution therefore reuses the snapshot instead of repeating the merged registry read - a transient failure there could fail-closed a tool the same turn already advertised from the successful first audit. - MCP.spec.js keeps @librechat/api pure helpers REAL (requireActual spread) so normalization paths are exercised rather than mirrored. * 🧯 fix: Parse Legacy Keys Against Both Server-Name Spellings createMCPTool's boundary candidates were normalized-only, so a legacy raw key whose server name contains the delimiter (foo_mcp_bar!) missed the suffix match and fell to the generic last-delimiter split - the canonical rebuild then produced a key that could never hit the index and the persisted call stubbed out. The candidate list now carries the RAW resolved name (and raw config names on the parse-only path) next to the normalized spellings. * 🧯 fix: Honest Audit Completeness; Shadowed-Server Form-Key Guard - resolveAllMcpConfigs tolerates ensureConfigServers failures, so the merged registry read can silently omit config-only servers while the audit still reported complete: true - a foo/foo! collision would go unseen and a persisted key could route to the wrong server. Both audit consumers now union the snapshot-derived raw config names back in (resolveCollisionAuditNames unions the caller's rawServerNames; the initializeAgent heal unions configRawServerNames), keeping the completeness label honest without an extra read: operator names come from the registry-independent config snapshot, user-DB names from the merged read that fails loudly into the existing incomplete path. - The client tool_options migration now mirrors the runtime heal's fail-closed rule for SHADOWED servers: when the dialog's server has lost its normalized slot to another catalog name, legacy raw keys stay raw instead of being rewritten onto the winning server's key, where a later save would apply the wrong server's per-tool settings. The dialog's own server joins the alias construction so a stale catalog map can't misread as a collision. * 🧯 fix: Heal Legacy Assistant MCP Tool Names on Save The assistants create/update controllers look tools up in the cached definitions by exact key, and the cache is now normalized-keyed - an assistant saved before the convention resubmits its raw-suffixed MCP name on every edit, so any save silently removed the tool. healMcpToolNames pre-heals the payload's tool list: a delimiter-bearing string that misses the cache resolves through the configured raw names (longest-suffix, boundary-exact) and rewrites to the normalized key only when that key actually exists in the cache. SHADOWED raw names stay raw and fail closed, mirroring the runtime heal; the config read happens only when a delimiter-bearing name actually misses, and read failures propagate (write path) rather than silently dropping tools. v2's update loop also stops re-reading the tool cache per iteration. * 🧯 fix: Full-Audit Shadow Set + Dedupe in the Assistant Key Heal - The assistant-save heal built its shadow set from operator config names alone, so a cross-tier collision (user-DB `foo` owning the normalized slot of operator `foo!`) looked unshadowed and the legacy key healed into the shared normalized name - which direct-first execution then binds to the DB server. The shadow set now comes from resolveCollisionAuditNames' full accessible audit, and an incomplete audit skips healing outright (every rewrite candidate is normalization-sensitive by construction, so raw-and-fail-closed is the only safe answer). - Healed string entries dedupe order-preserving: a payload carrying both spellings of the same tool collapses to one entry instead of expanding into duplicate function definitions the provider rejects. |
||
|
|
250aca375a
|
🔗 fix: Resolve MCP Tool-Key Boundary Against Configured Server Names (#14448)
* fix: resolve MCP tool-name delimiter collision at invocation time
MCP tool keys are identified internally as `${rawToolName}${mcp_delimiter}${serverName}`
(delimiter `_mcp_`). Several call sites parsed this back apart with a naive
`toolKey.split(Constants.mcp_delimiter)`, assuming the delimiter occurs exactly once.
When the raw upstream tool name itself contains the delimiter substring - which
happens whenever it's exposed through a gateway that prefixes aggregated tool names by
server (e.g. a gateway's own "gitlab-get_mcp_server_version" for GitLab's
"get_mcp_server_version" tool) - the combined key has the delimiter more than once.
`.split()` then produces more than two segments, and destructuring
`[toolName, serverName]` silently keeps only the first two, yielding a bogus server
name that matches no configured server. Tool listing still worked (a different code
path builds keys directly without re-splitting), but invocation failed with
`Tool {name} not found`, and `filterAuthorizedTools` rejected such keys outright as
malformed.
Add `splitMCPToolKey`, which splits on the *last* occurrence of the delimiter instead:
the server-name half is always LibreChat's own normalized suffix (guaranteed not to
contain the delimiter), while the raw tool-name half is untrusted and may legitimately
contain it. This matches `.split()`'s result whenever the delimiter occurs once, and
correctly resolves the collision case. Update the four call sites that parsed this
manually (`handleTools.js`, `MCP.js`, `mcp.js` controller, `filterAuthorizedTools` in
`v1.js`) plus one in the client (`useVisibleTools.ts`) to use it.
Fixes #14440
* fix: resolve MCP tool-key boundary against configured server names
splitMCPToolKey moves to librechat-data-provider so the client and backend
share one parser, and takes the configured server names when the caller has
them: the longest name the key actually ends with wins, which is exact.
Position alone cannot identify the boundary because both halves may contain
the delimiter. lastIndexOf alone fixes gateway-prefixed tool names but
regresses servers whose own name contains it, which ToolService.spec.js
already covered; the last-delimiter path now only serves as the fallback for
callers with no configured set.
Also converts the remaining first-occurrence parsers that the delimiter fix
missed - mcp/auth.ts (custom user vars silently unresolved), mcp/oauth/events.ts,
agents/initialize.ts, and the three client parsers that labelled tool calls
with the wrong server.
* fix: keep client tool-call labels on first-delimiter parsing
The three client parsers had deliberate, tested first-delimiter semantics
(ToolCall.test.tsx asserts the full server name for 'foo_mcp_bar' and the
synthetic 'oauth_mcp_server' call), and the client has no configured server
list in scope to resolve the boundary exactly, so they are left as they were.
Threads the configured names into the event-driven definition loader so it
resolves the same boundary as the authorization filter that admits the key,
and documents the one case that stays undecidable without provenance.
* fix: resolve tool-key boundary against all configured servers
resolveConfigServers only returns lazily-initialized config overrides -
ensureConfigServers skips unmodified YAML servers - so on a stock deployment
the known-name list was empty and suffix resolution never engaged. Adds
resolveMcpServerNames, which keeps every configured server in the normalized
form tool keys carry, and uses it at the loading, auth-map and definition
sites.
Background-tool eligibility now resolves against all configured names before
testing ephemeral membership, so a non-ephemeral server whose name ends in an
ephemeral one is no longer misclassified, and useVisibleTools resolves against
the server map it already receives.
* fix: use resolved server provenance and one app-config read
createMCPTool now uses the serverName loadTools already resolved for the key
and only parses as a fallback, so an unmodified YAML server whose name
contains the delimiter no longer resolves to the wrong server for auth,
reconnection and callTool.
resolveMcpServerContext derives config servers and all configured names from
a single getAppConfigForRequest, replacing two independent lookups on the
chat startup path, and degrades to empty like resolveConfigServers instead of
aborting tool loading when the config lookup fails.
* chore: drop unused resolveConfigServers import
* fix: forward server provenance on the all-tools path and read config once
createMCPTools builds each toolKey from the server name it already has but did
not forward it, so the sys__all__sys path re-derived it by parsing and bound
an unmodified YAML server whose name contains the delimiter to the wrong auth
and invocation context.
loadAgentTools now resolves the MCP server context once and threads it into
loadTools, replacing the second app-config read it had introduced on the
non-event-driven chat startup path.
* fix: carry resolved MCP server name through tool classification
definitions.ts resolves the server for each key and then dropped it when
building loadedTools, so buildToolClassification re-derived it with a
last-segment split and recorded 'Workspace' for a server configured as
'Google_mcp_Workspace'. The resolved name now rides along on the tool
instance and classification prefers it over re-parsing.
* fix: consume carried server name when extracting MCP servers
extractMCPServers re-derived the name with a last-segment split, so a server
configured as Google_mcp_Workspace resolved to Workspace and its instructions
were silently omitted. Prefers the name carried on the tool definition
instance, falling back to the split.
* fix: fail closed on ambiguous MCP keys when persisting server names
Persisted mcpServerNames grant agent-scoped access to a DB server by name
(ServerConfigsDB.getAccessibleServers), so a wrong guess exposes an unrelated
server to everyone who can view the agent. The last-segment split turned
search_mcp_Google_mcp_workspace into 'workspace'; such keys were previously
rejected outright at agent save, so admitting them opened this path.
Derives a name only from unambiguous single-delimiter keys. This is #12250's
guard moved to the boundary it was actually protecting, instead of blocking
tool admission.
* fix: keep DB server access for multi-delimiter tool keys
The fail-closed guard was wrong for the case this PR exists to fix. This index
only grants DB-backed servers, and DB names are slugs that cannot contain the
delimiter (generateServerNameFromTitle strips underscores), so the trailing
segment is always the real server for them - dropping it cost every consumer
of a gateway-prefixed tool their shared-agent access.
Also gates the MCP server-context lookup on the filtered MCP set, so an agent
with no MCP tools no longer pays an app-config read on startup.
* fix: resolve tool-call display names without breaking OAuth calls
The display parsers could not use the shared boundary parser because their
tested behavior depends on first-delimiter semantics. That constraint only
applies to synthetic MCP OAuth calls, whose tool half is always exactly
'oauth', so everything after the first delimiter is the server even when the
server name carries one.
splitToolCallName special-cases that form and defers to splitMCPToolKey for
real tool keys, so a gateway-prefixed tool now renders its own name and
server while oauth_mcp_foo_mcp_bar still resolves to foo_mcp_bar.
* fix: persist resolved MCP server provenance on agents
Deriving mcpServerNames from the tool key cannot tell a config server's
trailing segment from a real DB server name, so a config server named
a_mcp_b indexed an unrelated DB server b and shared the agent's viewers into
it. Neither string rule works: the suffix guess exposes, and failing closed
drops legitimate DB access for gateway-prefixed tools.
filterAuthorizedTools already resolves each tool's server against the merged
registry config, so it now collects those names and create, update and
duplicate persist them. No extra registry queries: the update path unions the
newly resolved names with what the agent already had, and duplicate replaces
the copied list rather than inheriting the source's servers.
Display parsing also takes the configured names, so a real tool call on a
delimiter-bearing server renders the right server and icon.
* test: teach MCP hook mocks about useMCPServerNames
Three specs mock ~/hooks/MCP with a hand-listed factory, so adding the hook
to ToolCall made useMCPServerNames undefined under test and every render
threw. Returns a stable array so the mock cannot perturb render counts.
* fix: rebuild agent MCP server index from surviving tools
Unioning the prior names kept a server indexed after its last tool was
detached, so viewers of a shared agent retained agent-scoped access to it.
The index is now rebuilt from the tools that survive the edit: a prior name
carries forward only while some retained tool still resolves to it, using the
agent's own persisted names as the candidate set, and the rebuild runs on any
tool change rather than only when a new MCP tool is added.
* fix: keep duplicate indexes on registry fallback and harden the oauth split
Duplication blanked mcpServerNames when the registry was unavailable, because
filterAuthorizedTools grandfathers the source's tools without resolving them -
the copy kept tools it could no longer resolve. Source names now carry forward
for the tools that still point at them.
splitToolCallName also treated any oauth_mcp_ prefix as a synthetic OAuth
call, so a genuine upstream tool by that name resolved to the wrong server. A
configured server name now decides when one matches, since a real key always
ends in its server, and the prefix only breaks ties for unconfigured servers.
* fix: thread configured server names through display parsing
parseToolName and getMCPServerName resolved context-free, so a configured
server whose name contains the delimiter showed the wrong server in grouped
tool summaries and subagent tool labels, and stacked icons missed its entry in
the icon map. Both take the configured names now, supplied by the components
that render them.
Adds the hook to SubagentCall's mock factory: the spec renders the real
component, so an unmocked useMCPServerNames would reach the query with no
provider.
* test: cover the auth-map boundary, server provenance and context fallback
Adds regression coverage for three behaviors this PR changed that no test
exercised: customUserVars resolving under the right plugin key for a
gateway-prefixed tool name (the failure that made these tools loadable but
unusable), the resolved server name reaching createMCPTool instead of being
re-parsed, and resolveMcpServerContext degrading to empty rather than
aborting tool loading when the config lookup fails.
Each was checked against a mutated source to confirm it fails when the
behavior is broken.
* fix: normalize server-name candidates and cover the boundary guard
Tool keys embed normalizeServerName's output while the config is keyed by the
raw name, so callers passing raw keys never matched a server whose name needs
normalizing and silently fell back to the last delimiter. filterAuthorizedTools
now maps normalized names back to their config key, and createMCPTool
normalizes its candidates.
Adds the cases an audit found surviving mutation: a configured name that is a
bare but not delimiter-aligned suffix must not match, an empty candidate list
behaves as no list, and splitToolCallName still falls back to the oauth prefix
when a list is supplied but nothing in it matches.
* fix: keep resolved server names when a non-owner retains MCP tools
The shared-agent path keeps an agent's existing MCP tools verbatim but supplied
no mcpServerNames, so persistence re-derived them and reduced a configured
server like Google_mcp_Workspace to Workspace - which ServerConfigsDB then
treats as a DB server, granting the agent's viewers access to an unrelated one.
Carries the existing resolved names across instead, and clears the index on the
owner path where every MCP tool is removed.
* fix: preserve resolved MCP names for every tools update
extractMCPServerNames was reachable from any caller that writes tools without
mcpServerNames - the Action edit path does exactly that - so a configured
Google_mcp_Workspace was reindexed as Workspace and ServerConfigsDB granted
shared-agent viewers an unrelated DB server by that name.
updateAgent now rebuilds the index from the agent's own resolved names: one
carries forward while a retained tool still resolves to it, and only keys
matching none of them fall back to derivation. Callers are safe by default
rather than by remembering to pass the set.
normalizeServerName moves to librechat-data-provider so the client can match
its candidates against tool keys, which embed the normalized form; the icon map
is keyed the same way since it is looked up with a parsed server name.
* refactor: move MCP context resolution into packages/api
New backend logic belongs in the TypeScript workspace per CLAUDE.md, with /api
kept to a thin wrapper. resolveMCPServerContext now lives in
packages/api/src/mcp/context.ts and takes ensureConfigServers by injection,
since the registry accessor is still legacy-only; the /api function is reduced
to loading the request app config and translating failures into the empty
degrade it already promised.
* test: teach the MCP service mock about resolveMCPServerContext
The spec mocks @librechat/api with a hand-listed factory, so moving the
resolver into that package left it undefined and the wrapper degraded into its
own catch, returning empty config servers. The stub mirrors the real resolver
so these tests still cover what the wrapper owns - loading the request config
and degrading on failure - while the resolution logic is unit-tested in
packages/api.
* fix: only persist an authoritative MCP server index on update
Assigning the resolved set unconditionally pinned the index to [] whenever
nothing authoritative was available - a legacy agent holding MCP tools with no
stored mcpServerNames - which suppressed updateAgent's derivation and stripped
agent-scoped access to its DB-backed server.
The field is now supplied only when the result is authoritative: names were
resolved, or no MCP tool survives so the index genuinely is empty. The
retained-tools branch likewise leaves it unset when the agent has none stored.
---------
Co-authored-by: Jens Schumann <schumajs@gmail.com>
|