test: Enumerate the Click UI Decisions the Theme Cannot Express (#16544)

Pin every Click UI parity decision to its verdict per mode (match, near, deviation, not expressible) instead of aggregate floors, so a swap fails by name. List the decisions no theme can reach today, each with its reason and tracking issue, and print a match/near/mismatch status for every color and appearance role against the Click UI token that names its job.

Every status is measured from a rendered primitive or a cited snapshot token: a missing token, a stylesheet rule the rendered popover no longer takes its corner from, a size or radius class no role resolves, an empty gap entry or a moved appearance decision all fail by name. The Button primary fill and height now match through the Button roles, so the Button leaves the list.

(cherry picked from commit a1b98bc724)

Original-PR: https://github.com/LibreChat-AI/LibreChat/pull/16544
This commit is contained in:
Marco Beretta 2026-09-30 10:01:00 +02:00 • committed by Lia
parent dd1cb0e5ba
commit 37f02c2897
2 changed files with 553 additions and 64 deletions

View file

@ -56,13 +56,18 @@
"global.color.background.default": "#ffffff",
"global.color.background.muted": "#f6f7fa",
"global.color.background.split": "#f6f7fa",
"global.color.chart.default.babyblue": "#00cbeb",
"global.color.chart.default.blue": "#437eef",
"global.color.chart.default.fuchsia": "#fb32c9",
"global.color.chart.default.green": "#00e513",
"global.color.chart.default.orange": "#ff7729",
"global.color.chart.default.teal": "#089b83",
"global.color.chart.default.violet": "#bb33ff",
"global.color.chart.default.yellow": "#eef400",
"global.color.feedback.danger.background": "#ffdddd",
"global.color.feedback.danger.foreground": "#c10000",
"global.color.feedback.info.background": "#e7effd",
"global.color.feedback.info.foreground": "#437eef",
"global.color.feedback.neutral.background": "#f6f7fa",
"global.color.feedback.neutral.foreground": "#53575f",
"global.color.feedback.neutral.stroke": "#e6e7e9",
@ -75,6 +80,7 @@
"global.color.stroke.intense": "#b3b6bd",
"global.color.text.default": "#161517",
"global.color.text.disabled": "#a0a0a0",
"global.color.text.link.default": "#437eef",
"global.color.text.link.hover": "#104ec6",
"global.color.text.muted": "#696e79",
"palette.babyblue.600": "#008599",
@ -114,7 +120,8 @@
"typography.font.sizes.2": "0.875rem",
"typography.font.sizes.3": "1rem",
"typography.font.sizes.4": "1.125rem",
"typography.font.sizes.5": "1.25rem"
"typography.font.sizes.5": "1.25rem",
"typography.font.sizes.6": "2rem"
},
"dark": {
"border.radii.1": "0.25rem",
@ -225,6 +232,7 @@
"typography.font.sizes.2": "0.875rem",
"typography.font.sizes.3": "1rem",
"typography.font.sizes.4": "1.125rem",
"typography.font.sizes.5": "1.25rem"
"typography.font.sizes.5": "1.25rem",
"typography.font.sizes.6": "2rem"
}
}

View file

@ -1,5 +1,7 @@
import { createElement } from 'react';
import { cleanup, render } from '@testing-library/react';
import { join } from 'path';
import { readFileSync } from 'fs';
import { cleanup, fireEvent, render } from '@testing-library/react';
import type { ReactElement } from 'react';
import type { IThemeAppearance, IThemeRGB, ThemeMode } from '../types';
import {
@ -39,6 +41,15 @@ type Rgba = [number, number, number, number];
type Snapshot = Record<ThemeMode, Record<string, string | number>>;
const tokens: Snapshot = { light: snapshot.light, dark: snapshot.dark };
/** A cited Click UI token, failing by name when the snapshot no longer carries it. */
function clickToken(mode: ThemeMode, token: string): string {
const value = tokens[mode][token];
if (value === undefined) {
throw new Error(`Click UI token ${token} is not in the ${mode} snapshot`);
}
return String(value);
}
const modes: ThemeMode[] = ['light', 'dark'];
const colorSources: Record<ThemeMode, Partial<Record<keyof IThemeRGB, string>>> = {
@ -272,19 +283,160 @@ const unsourcedColors: Record<ThemeMode, Partial<Record<keyof IThemeRGB, string>
},
};
/**
* How close a role lands on Click UI: `match` holds the token that names the role's job, `near` is
* within deltaE2000 5 of it, and `mismatch` is further off.
*/
type RoleStatus = 'match' | 'near' | 'mismatch';
interface Departure {
/** The Click UI token that names the role's job, which the theme's value departs from. */
counterpart: string;
status: Exclude<RoleStatus, 'match'>;
reason: string;
}
/**
* Roles whose value is not the Click UI token that names the same job, and why. Each one cites a
* step on the same Click UI ramp in `colorSources`; the status pins how far that step sits from
* the counterpart. Every other role holds its counterpart, so its status is `match`.
*/
const departures: Record<ThemeMode, Partial<Record<keyof IThemeRGB, Departure>>> = {
light: {
'rgb-text-secondary': {
counterpart: 'global.color.text.muted',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'text.muted is 4.05:1 on feedback.danger.background, where secondary copy also sits',
},
'rgb-text-secondary-alt': {
counterpart: 'global.color.text.muted',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'text.muted is 4.05:1 on feedback.danger.background, where secondary copy also sits',
},
'rgb-text-tertiary': {
counterpart: 'global.color.text.muted',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'text.muted is 4.05:1 on feedback.danger.background, where secondary copy also sits',
},
'rgb-link': {
counterpart: 'global.color.text.link.default',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'text.link.default is 3.84:1 on white',
},
'rgb-link-prose': {
counterpart: 'global.color.text.link.default',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'text.link.default is 3.84:1 on white',
},
'rgb-border-xheavy': {
counterpart: 'global.color.stroke.intense',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'stroke.intense is 2.03:1 on white, under the 3:1 a heavy edge carries',
},
'rgb-border-control': {
counterpart: 'click.field.color.stroke.default',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'field.color.stroke.default misses the 3:1 non-text floor for a control edge',
},
'rgb-status-success': {
counterpart: 'global.color.feedback.success.foreground',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'feedback.success.foreground is 4.27:1 on its own fill',
},
'rgb-status-info': {
counterpart: 'global.color.feedback.info.foreground',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'feedback.info.foreground is 3.32:1 on its own fill',
},
'rgb-series-2': {
counterpart: 'global.color.chart.default.orange',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'chart.default.orange is 2.65:1 on white, under the 3:1 a chart mark needs',
},
'rgb-series-3': {
counterpart: 'global.color.chart.default.green',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'chart.default.green is 1.72:1 on white, under the 3:1 a chart mark needs',
},
'rgb-series-5': {
counterpart: 'global.color.chart.default.yellow',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'chart.default.yellow is 1.19:1 on white, under the 3:1 a chart mark needs',
},
'rgb-series-7': {
counterpart: 'global.color.chart.default.babyblue',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'chart.default.babyblue is 1.95:1 on white, under the 3:1 a chart mark needs',
},
'rgb-switch-unchecked': {
counterpart: 'click.switch.color.background.default',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'switch.color.background.default misses the 3:1 non-text floor for the off track',
},
},
dark: {
'rgb-border-xheavy': {
counterpart: 'global.color.stroke.intense',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'stroke.intense is 1.62:1 on the canvas, under the 3:1 a heavy edge carries',
},
'rgb-border-control': {
counterpart: 'click.field.color.stroke.default',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'field.color.stroke.default misses the 3:1 non-text floor for a control edge',
},
'rgb-switch-unchecked': {
counterpart: 'click.switch.color.background.default',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'switch.color.background.default misses the 3:1 non-text floor for the off track',
},
'rgb-surface-overlay': {
counterpart: 'click.dialog.color.opaqueBackground.default',
status: 'mismatch',
reason: 'the dark scrim is a #606060 gray that lifts the page instead of dimming it',
},
},
};
interface AppearanceDecision {
/** The value the decision was made for; a theme that moves it has to revisit the decision. */
value: string;
/** The Click UI token the decision departs from, when it departs from one. */
token?: string;
status: RoleStatus;
reason: string;
}
/**
* Appearance choices that are a reading of Click UI rather than one of its values, and the
* evidence for each. Click UI gives every disabled control a fixed fill, ink and edge
* (`button.basic.color.primary.*.disabled`, `field.color.*.disabled`, `global.color.text.disabled`)
* and never fades one, so the theme paints them instead of dimming.
*/
const appearanceDecisions: Partial<Record<keyof IThemeAppearance, string>> = {
disabledStyle: 'fill: Click UI paints disabled controls in fixed disabled tokens, never opacity',
text2xl:
"1.5rem: Click UI's next size, font.sizes.6 (2rem), would pass Tailwind's unthemed text-3xl (1.875rem)",
buttonHeight:
'2rem: Click UI sizes its button by content, button.basic.space.y (0.2813rem) twice, a 0.875rem/1.5 label and a 1px stroke each side',
buttonHeightSm: '2rem: Click UI draws one button size, so the small step matches the default',
const appearanceDecisions: Partial<Record<keyof IThemeAppearance, AppearanceDecision>> = {
disabledStyle: {
value: 'fill',
status: 'match',
reason: 'fill: Click UI paints disabled controls in fixed disabled tokens, never opacity',
},
text2xl: {
value: '1.5rem',
token: 'typography.font.sizes.6',
status: 'mismatch',
reason:
"1.5rem: Click UI's next size, font.sizes.6 (2rem), would pass Tailwind's unthemed text-3xl (1.875rem)",
},
buttonHeight: {
value: '2rem',
status: 'match',
reason:
'2rem: Click UI sizes its button by content, button.basic.space.y (0.2813rem) twice, a 0.875rem/1.5 label and a 1px stroke each side',
},
buttonHeightSm: {
value: '2rem',
status: 'match',
reason: '2rem: Click UI draws one button size, so the small step matches the default',
},
};
const appearanceSources: Partial<Record<keyof IThemeAppearance, string>> = {
@ -413,6 +565,64 @@ const sameRgb = (theme: string, source: Rgba) => {
);
};
/** sRGB channels to CIE L*a*b* under D65. */
function toLab([r, g, b]: Rgba): [number, number, number] {
const linear = (value: number) => {
const c = value / 255;
return c <= 0.04045 ? c / 12.92 : ((c + 0.055) / 1.055) ** 2.4;
};
const [lr, lg, lb] = [linear(r), linear(g), linear(b)];
const f = (t: number) => (t > 216 / 24389 ? Math.cbrt(t) : ((24389 / 27) * t + 16) / 116);
const x = f((0.4124564 * lr + 0.3575761 * lg + 0.1804375 * lb) / 0.95047);
const y = f(0.2126729 * lr + 0.7151522 * lg + 0.072175 * lb);
const z = f((0.0193339 * lr + 0.119192 * lg + 0.9503041 * lb) / 1.08883);
return [116 * y - 16, 500 * (x - y), 200 * (y - z)];
}
/** CIEDE2000 color difference; under 5 reads as the same color at a glance. */
function deltaE(first: Rgba, second: Rgba): number {
const [l1, a1, b1] = toLab(first);
const [l2, a2, b2] = toLab(second);
const rad = Math.PI / 180;
const chromaMean = (Math.hypot(a1, b1) + Math.hypot(a2, b2)) / 2;
const g = 0.5 * (1 - Math.sqrt(chromaMean ** 7 / (chromaMean ** 7 + 25 ** 7)));
const c1 = Math.hypot(a1 * (1 + g), b1);
const c2 = Math.hypot(a2 * (1 + g), b2);
const hue = (b: number, a: number) => (((Math.atan2(b, a) / rad) % 360) + 360) % 360;
const h1 = c1 === 0 ? 0 : hue(b1, a1 * (1 + g));
const h2 = c2 === 0 ? 0 : hue(b2, a2 * (1 + g));
const hueStep = c1 * c2 === 0 ? 0 : ((h2 - h1 + 540) % 360) - 180;
const deltaH = 2 * Math.sqrt(c1 * c2) * Math.sin((hueStep / 2) * rad);
const lMean = (l1 + l2) / 2;
const cMean = (c1 + c2) / 2;
const wraps = c1 * c2 !== 0 && Math.abs(h1 - h2) > 180;
const hMean = c1 * c2 === 0 ? h1 + h2 : (h1 + h2 + (wraps ? 360 : 0)) / 2;
const t =
1 -
0.17 * Math.cos((hMean - 30) * rad) +
0.24 * Math.cos(2 * hMean * rad) +
0.32 * Math.cos((3 * hMean + 6) * rad) -
0.2 * Math.cos((4 * hMean - 63) * rad);
const sl = 1 + (0.015 * (lMean - 50) ** 2) / Math.sqrt(20 + (lMean - 50) ** 2);
const sc = 1 + 0.045 * cMean;
const sh = 1 + 0.015 * cMean * t;
const rotation =
-2 *
Math.sqrt(cMean ** 7 / (cMean ** 7 + 25 ** 7)) *
Math.sin(60 * Math.exp(-(((hMean - 275) / 25) ** 2)) * rad);
const dl = (l2 - l1) / sl;
const dc = (c2 - c1) / sc;
const dh = deltaH / sh;
return Math.sqrt(dl ** 2 + dc ** 2 + dh ** 2 + rotation * dc * dh);
}
const NEAR = 5;
const tripletRgba = (triplet: string): Rgba => {
const [r, g, b] = triplet.split(' ').map(Number);
return [r, g, b, 1];
};
/** Every color function in a shadow list, rewritten to one form so both sides compare. */
const normalizeShadow = (value: string) =>
value
@ -458,8 +668,11 @@ function comparable(key: keyof IThemeAppearance, raw: string | number): string {
* nothing for a decision reads as transparent, no border or square, and text with no color of its
* own inherits the body copy (`text-primary`).
*
* The score is how many decisions match, per mode. Run with `CLICKUI_PARITY_REPORT=1` to print
* every decision; the floors below only move up.
* Every decision is pinned per mode: `match`, `near` (a color within deltaE2000 5), `deviation` (a
* departure the theme makes on purpose, with its reason), or `not expressible` (listed in
* `notExpressible` with the issue that tracks the missing role). A decision that improves or
* regresses fails by name, so move its pin when a change closes a gap. Run with
* `CLICKUI_PARITY_REPORT=1` to print every decision and every role's status.
*/
type ParityKind = 'color' | 'shape';
type Utility = 'bg' | 'text' | 'border' | 'rounded' | 'w' | 'h' | 'py' | 'px' | 'gap';
@ -472,9 +685,13 @@ interface ParityProbe {
/** A state the utility is written under, such as `data-[state=checked]:`. */
variant?: string;
/** Renders the primitive and returns the element that paints the decision. */
element: () => Element;
/** Why the theme departs from Click UI on purpose, when it does. */
deviation?: string;
element?: () => Element;
/** The value a stylesheet draws for the decision, when no class a theme role backs does. */
literal?: () => string;
/** The modes where the theme lands within deltaE2000 5 of Click UI rather than on it. */
near?: ThemeMode[];
/** Why the theme departs from Click UI on purpose, per mode. */
deviation?: Partial<Record<ThemeMode, string>>;
}
function mount(tree: ReactElement, selector: string): Element {
@ -534,6 +751,45 @@ const dropdownProbe = () =>
'[role="combobox"]',
);
/** The value of `property` in the first `selector` rule of a primitive's stylesheet. */
const stylesheetValue = (file: string, selector: string, property: string) => () => {
const css = readFileSync(join(__dirname, '../../components', file), 'utf8');
const start = css.indexOf(`${selector} {`);
const rule = start === -1 ? '' : css.slice(start, css.indexOf('}', start));
const value = new RegExp(`${property}:\\s*([^;]+);`).exec(rule)?.[1];
if (value === undefined) {
throw new Error(`${file} has no ${property} in a ${selector} rule`);
}
return value;
};
/**
* The open Dropdown menu's corner. jsdom loads no stylesheet, so the rendered popover is checked
* to take its corner from `.popover-ui` alone (no radius utility or inline radius overrides it)
* before the rule's value is read.
*/
const popoverCorner = () => {
try {
fireEvent.click(dropdownProbe());
const popover = document.querySelector<HTMLElement>('[role="listbox"]');
if (!popover?.classList.contains('popover-ui')) {
throw new Error('The open Dropdown menu no longer carries .popover-ui');
}
const override = [...popover.classList].find((name) => /^rounded(-|$)/.test(name));
if (override !== undefined || popover.style.borderRadius !== '') {
throw new Error(`The open Dropdown menu sets its own corner (${override ?? 'inline'})`);
}
return stylesheetValue('Dropdown.css', '.popover-ui', 'border-radius')();
} finally {
cleanup();
}
};
const bothModes = (reason: string): Partial<Record<ThemeMode, string>> => ({
light: reason,
dark: reason,
});
const buttonProbe = (variant: 'default' | 'outline') => () =>
mount(createElement(Button, { variant }, 'Save'), 'button');
@ -559,6 +815,7 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
kind: 'color',
utility: 'border',
element: buttonProbe('outline'),
near: ['dark'],
},
'Button corner': {
token: 'border.radii.1',
@ -571,7 +828,6 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
kind: 'shape',
utility: 'h',
element: buttonProbe('default'),
deviation: 'Click UI sizes its button by content; the 32px it draws is the menu row height',
},
'Button inline padding': {
token: 'click.button.basic.space.x',
@ -596,7 +852,9 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
kind: 'color',
utility: 'border',
element: inputProbe,
deviation: 'border-control holds form controls to the 3:1 non-text floor stroke.default misses',
deviation: bothModes(
'border-control holds form controls to the 3:1 non-text floor stroke.default misses',
),
},
'Field text': {
token: 'click.field.color.text.default',
@ -615,7 +873,9 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
kind: 'color',
utility: 'border',
element: dropdownProbe,
deviation: 'border-control holds form controls to the 3:1 non-text floor stroke.default misses',
deviation: bothModes(
'border-control holds form controls to the 3:1 non-text floor stroke.default misses',
),
},
'Dropdown trigger corner': {
token: 'border.radii.1',
@ -623,6 +883,12 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
utility: 'rounded',
element: dropdownProbe,
},
'Dropdown menu corner': {
token: 'border.radii.1',
kind: 'shape',
utility: 'rounded',
literal: popoverCorner,
},
'Dialog surface': {
token: 'click.dialog.color.background.default',
kind: 'color',
@ -640,12 +906,16 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
kind: 'color',
utility: 'text',
element: dialogProbe('h2'),
near: ['light', 'dark'],
},
'Dialog scrim': {
token: 'click.dialog.color.opaqueBackground.default',
kind: 'color',
utility: 'bg',
element: dialogProbe('.inset-0'),
deviation: {
dark: 'surface-overlay keeps the dark scrim black; Click UI #606060 lifts the page it covers',
},
},
'Dialog corner': {
token: 'click.dialog.radii.all',
@ -666,7 +936,10 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
utility: 'bg',
variant: 'data-[state=unchecked]:',
element: switchProbe(false),
deviation: 'switch-unchecked holds the off track to the 3:1 non-text floor #cccfd3 misses',
deviation: {
light: 'switch-unchecked holds the off track to the 3:1 non-text floor #cccfd3 misses',
dark: 'switch-unchecked holds the off track to the 3:1 non-text floor #606060 misses',
},
},
'Switch thumb': {
token: 'click.switch.color.indicator.default',
@ -740,13 +1013,16 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
kind: 'shape',
utility: 'rounded',
element: tableProbe('div'),
deviation: 'the table has no frame of its own; each consumer draws the panel it sits in',
deviation: bothModes(
'the table has no frame of its own; each consumer draws the panel it sits in',
),
},
'Badge fill': {
token: 'click.badge.opaque.color.background.default',
kind: 'color',
utility: 'bg',
element: badgeProbe,
near: ['light'],
},
'Badge label': {
token: 'click.badge.opaque.color.text.default',
@ -768,12 +1044,64 @@ const parityProbes: Record<string, ParityProbe> = {
},
};
/** The fewest decisions per mode that must match; raise a floor when a change closes a gap. */
const parityFloors: Record<ThemeMode, Record<ParityKind, number>> = {
light: { color: 10, shape: 13 },
dark: { color: 10, shape: 13 },
interface NotExpressible {
/** The parity decisions the gap leaves unmatched, per mode. */
decisions: Partial<Record<ThemeMode, string[]>>;
/** Why no theme can reach Click UI's value today. */
reason: string;
/** The berry-13/LibreChat issue that tracks the role or change that closes it. */
issue: string;
}
/**
* Every Click UI decision the theme engine cannot express, and why. Each one needs a role or a
* primitive change that keeps the default theme pixel-identical; a theme's values alone cannot
* close it. Remove an entry when the change that closes it lands, and pin its decisions to what
* they then measure.
*/
const notExpressible: Record<string, NotExpressible> = {
'Field fill and ink': {
decisions: { light: ['Field fill', 'Field text'], dark: ['Field fill', 'Field text'] },
reason:
'the field is transparent and inks with text-primary; a color role is an opaque triplet, so no role can default to no fill, and no role holds field ink apart from body copy',
issue: 'https://github.com/berry-13/LibreChat/issues/206',
},
'Dialog edge': {
decisions: { light: ['Dialog stroke'], dark: ['Dialog stroke'] },
reason:
'the dialog draws no border and no role sets a dialog stroke width, so a 1px edge would change the default dialog',
issue: 'https://github.com/berry-13/LibreChat/issues/138',
},
'Badge label': {
decisions: { light: ['Badge label'], dark: ['Badge label'] },
reason:
'Badge inks with text-primary; Click UI labels badges in text.muted, and no role holds badge ink apart from body copy',
issue: 'https://github.com/berry-13/LibreChat/issues/143',
},
'Dropdown menu corner': {
decisions: { light: ['Dropdown menu corner'], dark: ['Dropdown menu corner'] },
reason:
'the popover corner is a 0.7rem literal in Dropdown.css, and no radius role defaults to 0.7rem',
issue: 'https://github.com/berry-13/LibreChat/issues/196',
},
};
type Verdict = 'match' | 'near' | 'deviation' | 'not expressible';
const notExpressibleGap = (mode: ThemeMode, decision: string) =>
Object.entries(notExpressible).find(([, gap]) => gap.decisions[mode]?.includes(decision))?.[0];
/** What a decision is pinned to in `mode`. */
function pinnedVerdict(mode: ThemeMode, decision: string, probe: ParityProbe): Verdict {
if (notExpressibleGap(mode, decision) !== undefined) {
return 'not expressible';
}
if (probe.deviation?.[mode] !== undefined) {
return 'deviation';
}
return probe.near?.includes(mode) ? 'near' : 'match';
}
const radiusRoles: Record<string, keyof IThemeAppearance> = {
sm: 'radiusSm',
md: 'radiusMd',
@ -844,6 +1172,11 @@ function roleColor(resolved: Resolved, name: string): Rgba | undefined {
if (role === 'transparent') {
return [0, 0, 0, 0];
}
/** `bg-scrim` is `surface-overlay` at the theme's scrim opacity (`--color-scrim` in tokens.css). */
if (role === 'scrim') {
const [r, g, b] = tripletRgba(resolved.colors['rgb-surface-overlay']);
return [r, g, b, Number(resolved.appearance.scrimOpacity)];
}
const triplet = resolved.colors[`rgb-${role}` as keyof IThemeRGB];
if (triplet === undefined) {
return undefined;
@ -898,40 +1231,107 @@ function shapeValue(utility: Utility, role: string | undefined, resolved: Resolv
if (role === undefined) {
return utility === 'rounded' ? '0px' : 'auto';
}
if (isSizeUtility(utility)) {
return sizeValue(utility, role, resolved) ?? 'auto';
const value = isSizeUtility(utility)
? sizeValue(utility, role, resolved)
: (fixedRadii[role] ?? resolved.appearance[radiusRoles[role]]);
if (value === undefined) {
throw new Error(`No theme role or scale step resolves ${utility}-${role}`);
}
return fixedRadii[role] ?? resolved.appearance[radiusRoles[role]];
return value;
}
/** `off` is any departure past near; the pin says whether it is a deviation or a gap. */
type Measured = 'match' | 'near' | 'off';
interface ParityResult {
decision: string;
kind: ParityKind;
match: boolean;
measured: Measured;
theme: string;
clickUi: string;
deviation?: string;
}
const nearColor = (a: Rgba, b: Rgba) => Math.abs(a[3] - b[3]) < 0.01 && deltaE(a, b) < NEAR;
function measure(mode: ThemeMode, decision: string, probe: ParityProbe): ParityResult {
const source = clickToken(mode, probe.token);
const base = { decision, clickUi: source };
if (probe.literal) {
const value = probe.literal();
return { ...base, theme: `literal = ${value}`, measured: value === source ? 'match' : 'off' };
}
if (!probe.element) {
throw new Error(`Parity probe ${decision} has neither an element nor a literal`);
}
const resolved = resolveTheme(clickHouseTheme, mode);
const element = probe.element();
const source = tokens[mode][probe.token];
const role =
probe.utility === 'text'
? inheritedTextRole(element, probe, resolved)
: paintedRole(element, probe, resolved);
cleanup();
const base = { decision, kind: probe.kind, clickUi: source, deviation: probe.deviation };
const painted = role === undefined ? 'unpainted' : `${probe.utility}-${role}`;
if (probe.kind === 'shape') {
const theme = shapeValue(probe.utility, role, resolved);
const painted = role === undefined ? 'unpainted' : `${probe.utility}-${role}`;
return { ...base, theme: `${painted} = ${theme}`, match: theme === source };
return {
...base,
theme: `${painted} = ${theme}`,
measured: theme === source ? 'match' : 'off',
};
}
const color = role === undefined ? ([0, 0, 0, 0] as Rgba) : roleColor(resolved, role);
const painted = role === undefined ? 'unpainted' : `${probe.utility}-${role}`;
const theme = `${painted} = ${color ? formatRgba(color) : 'unresolved'}`;
return { ...base, theme, match: color !== undefined && sameColor(color, clickColor(source)) };
if (color === undefined) {
return { ...base, theme, measured: 'off' };
}
const clickUi = clickColor(source);
if (sameColor(color, clickUi)) {
return { ...base, theme, measured: 'match' };
}
return { ...base, theme, measured: nearColor(color, clickUi) ? 'near' : 'off' };
}
/** The status of every color role against the Click UI token that names its job. */
function roleStatuses(mode: ThemeMode): Array<[keyof IThemeRGB, RoleStatus, string]> {
const colors = clickHouseTheme.modes[mode]?.colors ?? {};
return (Object.keys(colors) as Array<keyof IThemeRGB>).map((key) => {
const departure = departures[mode][key];
const token = departure?.counterpart ?? colorSources[mode][key];
if (token === undefined) {
return [key, 'mismatch', 'unsourced'];
}
const theme = tripletRgba(colors[key] ?? '');
const counterpart = clickColor(clickToken(mode, token));
const distance = deltaE(theme, counterpart);
const departed: RoleStatus = distance < NEAR ? 'near' : 'mismatch';
const status = sameRgb(colors[key] ?? '', counterpart) ? 'match' : departed;
const why = departure === undefined ? '' : `: ${departure.reason}`;
return [key, status, `${token} dE ${distance.toFixed(2)}${why}`];
});
}
/** The status of every appearance role the theme sets. */
function appearanceStatuses(mode: ThemeMode): Array<[keyof IThemeAppearance, RoleStatus, string]> {
const appearance = clickHouseTheme.modes[mode]?.appearance ?? {};
return (Object.keys(appearance) as Array<keyof IThemeAppearance>).map((key) => {
const decision = appearanceDecisions[key];
if (decision?.token !== undefined) {
const source = clickToken(mode, decision.token);
const same = comparable(key, String(appearance[key])) === comparable(key, source);
return [key, same ? 'match' : 'mismatch', `${decision.token} ${source}: ${decision.reason}`];
}
if (decision !== undefined) {
return [key, decision.status, decision.reason];
}
const token = appearanceSources[key] ?? 'unsourced';
const theme = String(appearance[key]);
const source = clickToken(mode, token);
if (comparable(key, theme) !== comparable(key, source)) {
return [key, 'mismatch', token];
}
/** The mono stack leads with Click UI's face and keeps the default theme's tail. */
const verbatim = theme.replace(/;$/, '').trim() === source.replace(/;$/, '').trim();
return [key, verbatim || key !== 'monoFontFamily' ? 'match' : 'near', token];
});
}
describe('ClickHouse theme drift against Click UI', () => {
@ -1000,7 +1400,9 @@ describe('ClickHouse theme drift against Click UI', () => {
it.each(modes)('keeps only the %s tokens the theme cites in the snapshot', (mode) => {
const cited = new Set([
...Object.values(colorSources[mode]),
...Object.values(departures[mode]).map((departure) => departure.counterpart),
...Object.values(appearanceSources),
...Object.values(appearanceDecisions).flatMap(({ token }) => (token ? [token] : [])),
...Object.values(parityProbes).map((probe) => probe.token),
]);
@ -1009,36 +1411,115 @@ describe('ClickHouse theme drift against Click UI', () => {
});
describe('ClickHouse primitive parity against Click UI components', () => {
it.each(modes)('matches at least the recorded number of %s decisions', (mode) => {
const results = Object.entries(parityProbes).map(([decision, probe]) =>
measure(mode, decision, probe),
);
const score = (kind: ParityKind) => {
const scoped = results.filter((result) => result.kind === kind);
const matched = scoped.filter((result) => result.match).length;
return { matched, total: scoped.length };
};
const color = score('color');
const shape = score('shape');
const report = (lines: string[]) => {
if (process.env.CLICKUI_PARITY_REPORT) {
const verdict = ({ match, deviation }: ParityResult) => {
if (match) {
return 'match';
}
return deviation ? 'deviation' : 'gap';
};
const rows = results.map(
(result) => `${verdict(result)}\t${result.decision}\t${result.theme}\t${result.clickUi}`,
);
const percent = ({ matched, total }: { matched: number; total: number }) =>
`${matched}/${total} (${((matched / total) * 100).toFixed(1)}%)`;
console.info(
[`${mode}: color ${percent(color)}, shape ${percent(shape)}`, ...rows].join('\n'),
);
console.info(lines.join('\n'));
}
};
expect(color.matched).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(parityFloors[mode].color);
expect(shape.matched).toBeGreaterThanOrEqual(parityFloors[mode].shape);
it.each(modes)('lands every %s decision on its pinned verdict', (mode) => {
const rows = Object.entries(parityProbes).map(([decision, probe]) => {
const pinned = pinnedVerdict(mode, decision, probe);
const result = measure(mode, decision, probe);
const why = probe.deviation?.[mode] ?? notExpressibleGap(mode, decision) ?? '';
return { pinned, result, why };
});
const tally = rows.reduce<Record<string, number>>(
(counts, { pinned }) => ({ ...counts, [pinned]: (counts[pinned] ?? 0) + 1 }),
{},
);
report([
`${mode}: ${rows.length} decisions ${JSON.stringify(tally)}`,
...rows.map(
({ pinned, result, why }) =>
`${pinned}\t${result.decision}\t${result.theme}\t${result.clickUi}\t${why}`,
),
]);
const expected = (pinned: Verdict): Measured =>
pinned === 'match' || pinned === 'near' ? pinned : 'off';
const moved = rows
.filter(({ pinned, result }) => result.measured !== expected(pinned))
.map(
({ pinned, result }) =>
`${result.decision}: pinned ${pinned}, measures ${result.measured} (${result.theme}, Click UI ${result.clickUi})`,
);
expect(moved).toEqual([]);
});
it('keeps the not-expressible list to real, tracked, unmatched decisions', () => {
const problems = Object.entries(notExpressible).flatMap(
([gap, { decisions, reason, issue }]) => [
...(reason.trim() === '' ? [`${gap}: no reason`] : []),
...(Object.values(decisions).some((listed) => (listed?.length ?? 0) > 0)
? []
: [`${gap}: names no decision`]),
...(/^https:\/\/github\.com\/berry-13\/LibreChat\/issues\/\d+$/.test(issue)
? []
: [`${gap}: ${issue} is not a berry-13/LibreChat issue`]),
...modes.flatMap((mode) =>
(decisions[mode] ?? []).flatMap((decision) => {
const probe = parityProbes[decision];
if (probe === undefined) {
return [`${gap}: ${decision} is not a parity decision`];
}
if (notExpressibleGap(mode, decision) !== gap) {
return [`${gap}: ${mode} ${decision} is listed under another gap too`];
}
return probe.deviation?.[mode] === undefined && probe.near?.includes(mode) !== true
? []
: [`${gap}: ${mode} ${decision} is also pinned near or deviation`];
}),
),
],
);
report([
`not expressible: ${Object.keys(notExpressible).length}`,
...Object.entries(notExpressible).map(
([gap, { reason, issue }]) => `${gap}\t${issue}\t${reason}`,
),
]);
expect(problems).toEqual([]);
});
it.each(modes)('pins the %s status of every color role against Click UI', (mode) => {
const statuses = roleStatuses(mode);
const count = (status: RoleStatus) => statuses.filter(([, value]) => value === status).length;
report([
`${mode} roles: match ${count('match')}, near ${count('near')}, mismatch ${count('mismatch')}`,
...statuses.map(([key, status, detail]) => `${status}\t${key}\t${detail}`),
]);
const moved = statuses.flatMap(([key, status]) => {
const pinned = departures[mode][key]?.status ?? 'match';
return status === pinned ? [] : [`${key}: pinned ${pinned}, measures ${status}`];
});
const stale = Object.keys(departures[mode]).filter(
(key) => !statuses.some(([role]) => role === key),
);
expect({ moved, stale }).toEqual({ moved: [], stale: [] });
});
it.each(modes)('pins the %s status of every appearance role against Click UI', (mode) => {
const statuses = appearanceStatuses(mode);
report([
`${mode} appearance:`,
...statuses.map(([key, status, detail]) => `${status}\t${key}\t${detail}`),
]);
const appearance = clickHouseTheme.modes[mode]?.appearance ?? {};
const moved = Object.entries(appearanceDecisions).flatMap(([key, { value }]) => {
const theme = String(appearance[key as keyof IThemeAppearance]);
return theme === value ? [] : [`${key}: decided at ${value}, the theme sets ${theme}`];
});
expect(moved).toEqual([]);
expect(statuses.filter(([, status]) => status === 'mismatch').map(([key]) => key)).toEqual([
'text2xl',
]);
expect(statuses.filter(([, status]) => status === 'near').map(([key]) => key)).toEqual([
'monoFontFamily',
]);
});
});